Tie Showdown: Week ?

From top to bottom, left to right:

Amber

Tie Showdown: Week 48

From top to bottom, left to right:
Liz : Jeff : Ben : Adam

Tie Showdown: Week Mutha Flippin' SUMMER BREAK

From top to bottom, left to right:

Tiny Dancer : Stevie : Spider Bite : Skyler : Puddles : Pappi : Miller : Hooks : Harry : Bubbles : Ballpoint

Tie Showdown: Week 44

From top to bottom, left to right
Jeff : Colin : Byron : Ben : Adam

Weeks 42 and 43: And the winners are...

Joni wins her first wooden key in Week 42, and Adam wins his third in Week 43!

Tie Showdown: Week 43

From top to bottom, left to right:
Vanessa : Roslynn : Megan : Liz : Lane : JP : Jim : Jeff : Hillary : Gary : Emily : Colin : Chris : Byron : Ben : Emilia : Adam

Tie Showdown: Week 42

From top to bottom, left to right:
Zach : Lane : Joni : Jim : Jeff : Dominique : Dan : Cat : Ben : Adam